Tag Archives: tax extension

Client Options for Claiming The Employee Retention Credit (ERC)

Note to readers: the issue outlined below only applies to 50%-or-greater shareholders — which means the business is a corporation — and their spouses who work at the company. It does not apply to sole proprietors or partners — those two groups do not get paid via payroll and therefore are not eligible. Shareholders who own less than 50% are eligible if the business meets the other requirements to claim the credit.

If you are a 50%-or-greater shareholder and your company qualifies for the Employee Retention Credit for either 2020 or 2021, please read on.


I truly cannot believe that it’s June 2021 and I’m writing a blog post to help people choose the least-worst 2020 Employee Retention Credit interpretation — because even though the pandemic is starting to show in our rearview mirrors, we are still living in a universe totally devoid of IRS guidance on the topic of ERC shareholder eligibility. Accountants jokingly refer to this mystery as the Tax Advisers’ “Area 51” on #TaxTwitter.

What am I talking about? And why am I so annoyed? Let me set the scene:

1) Many small business owners are eligible retroactively for the 2020 Employee Retention Credit (ERC), and the IRS decided that the corresponding reduction in wages for that credit needs to be on the 2020 tax return.

2) However, the company’s Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Forgiveness application needs to be prepared before calculating the amount of the ERC, in order to maximize the amount of financial relief the client receives between the two programs. Therefore, at our firm, these returns are all on extension while we run these calculations.

3) Now that the first round of PPP loans are nearing the end of the payment deferment period — and to be fair, we’re also only a few months away from the tax return extension deadline — we would like to finalize those calculations and returns. (Reminder: there is no “deadline” for applying for PPP Forgiveness — per the SBA, “borrowers can apply for forgiveness any time up to the maturity date of the loan. If borrowers do not apply for forgiveness within 10 months after the last day of the covered period, then PPP loan payments are no longer deferred, and borrowers will begin making loan payments to their PPP lender.”)

4) The catch is — that the IRS has still not released guidance on whether or not 50%+ owners of a corporation are eligible for the credit (or their spouses who work for the business). Accountants are split down the middle on what the existing legislation, which is extremely unclear, tells us on the topic. As such, we either need to take a position or continue to wait for IRS guidance.

What’s that? You’re saying the IRS has still not issued essential guidance on a credit that was created in the first month of the pandemic? Yes. Yes, I am.

Recently, both the AICPA and Tony Nitti, two of my most trusted sources, have weighed in on this with a big “why is the IRS dragging their heels on this” reaction. Nitti went as far as to say, “Are wages paid to greater than 50% owners eligible for the credit? If I had a nickel for every time someone emailed me this question, I could afford to stop shamelessly and relentlessly shilling this newsletter. It is absolutely amazing that a full year after the ERC was created, we still don’t have a definitive answer.”

Okay, enough backstory. As a small business owner, what are your options? I call them Choice 1 (yes) and Choice 2 (no) for short:

  • #1 Calculate ERC as if owners are eligible and file 2020 income tax returns accordingly. This would result in a higher tax for clients (because more wages are disallowed as deductions). Submit PPP Forgiveness applications, but hold off on submitting ERC claims (941-Xs) until guidance is released. If guidance indicates that owners are eligible, file the ERC claims accordingly. If guidance says owners are not eligible, then amend the income tax returns and file the ERC claims accordingly.

This approach may make the most sense when there are two 50%-owners on payroll, and not many other other staff — as the increased credit would be worth the wait, compared to the total credit without owners.

  • #2 Calculate ERC as if owners are not eligible and file 2020 income tax returns accordingly. This would result in a lower tax for clients (because fewer wages are disallowed as deductions). Submit PPP Forgiveness applications, and submit ERC claims (941-Xs) — rather than holding off on these as in the above option. If guidance is eventually released that indicates owners are not eligible, then no action is needed. If guidance indicates that owners are eligible, then decide whether it is worth amending the income tax returns and ERC claims to get the additional funds.

This approach may make the most sense with only one 50%+ owner and many employees, as the cost to amend all returns and claims will probably not be worth the additional credit.

The goal with both approaches is to get PPP Forgiveness applications and tax returns filed as soon as possible, with the best balance between wage deductions and potential wage credits.

While I was tempted to pick one of these two approaches and inform all clients of our choice, I decided — especially with advice from an AICPA Town Hall — that this is a decision that each client needs to make for themselves. We’re happy to explain the potential costs and benefits of each approach and make a personal recommendation for each client’s individual situation, but the decision should be theirs. We recommend other CPA firms take a similar approach.


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

How To Pay Illinois Dept Of Revenue (IDOR) Individual Tax Extension Payments Online

The key to making extension payments online with the Illinois Department of Revenue is that — for non-business payments — there is no registration or login needed. In fact, you should make sure NOT to log in using the business credentials you might otherwise use for sales taxes or business income taxes.

Instead, simply go to MyTax Illinois, do NOT sign in, and click the button that says “Make an Individual Income Tax payment”. (See screen shot above.)

It will walk you through the Non-Login Payment screens, starting with the following:

Make sure to enter your SSN (not your business EIN), and then click the “Look up my IL-PIN” blue link to the right of the field. It will take you to a verification screen:

When you re-enter your SSN here and select one of the options, it only takes a few moments for the system to return a PIN number that you should copy and enter onto the previous screen. (Pro tip: if you’re using Adjusted Gross Income, use Line 1 from your most recently-filed Illinois tax return — it’s easier to find than AGI from your Federal return, and that way you know it will match Illinois’ records.)

On the next screen, enter the payment type:

In this case, since you’re filing an extension, you want the “IL-505-I Payment”.

(The other options are for quarterly estimated tax payments — IL-1040 Estimated Payment — or for a balance-due with your actual annual state income tax return — IL-1040 Payment. Since this is for an extension, you’ll pick the final one.)

Then you’ll select the tax year for the extension:

Lastly, you’ll enter bank information, payment amount, and date of payment.

Click “Submit” and PRINT/SAVE A COPY OF THE CONFIRMATION PAGE. I know they’ll email this to you, but every once-in-a-while something goes wrong, and it’s good to have proof that you attempted paying on-time.

While you’re at it, send a copy of that confirmation page to your dedicated accountant!


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

What Does A Tax Extension Mean For You?

It’s that time again… Tax Day (May 17th this year, aka my birthday) is upon us and it’s the end of what is certainly one of — if not the — roughest tax seasons in history. Millions of taxpayers will need to have their returns extended for various reasons. What does this mean? The AICPA has released a “Tax Extension FAQ” for CPA members to share with their clients.

What does filing an “extension” do?

• An extension is a form filed with the IRS to request additional time to file your federal tax return. This extends the due date for submitting your individual return to October 15. In some states, filing an extension with the IRS will automatically extend the time to complete a state income tax return.
• Filing an extension grants you additional time to submit your complete and accurate return, but you still need to estimate whether you will owe any taxes and pay that estimated balance by the original due date.
• Extending your return allows you and your CPA more time to prepare your tax return to ensure the filing of an accurate tax return. In many cases, you may still be waiting for additional information (e.g., Schedules K-1, corrected Forms 1099, etc.) to complete your return.

Why does my CPA suggest we extend my tax return?

• If your CPA has recommended that you file an extension, it may be due to many reasons, such as:
– The volume of data or complexity of certain transactions (e.g., sale of a rental property) on your return requires additional time.
– The amount of time remaining in filing season is limited for the CPA to complete client returns by the due date* due to late-arriving information.
– My note: this year exacerbated the situation by requiring small business CPAs to simultaneously navigate the Restaurant Relief Fund (RRF), PPP1 Forgiveness, and 2020 Employee Retention Credit.
• Many CPAs have a “cutoff” or deadline for clients submitting their tax information so they can plan their workload to ensure all client returns and extensions are completed by the due date.*
• Your CPA may suggest filing an extension if there are aspects of your return affected by pending guidance or legislation.
My note: this is the case for many more clients this year than usual; late-changing tax rules delayed the start of tax season, and waiting for guidance has further stretched it thin.

Am I more likely to be audited if I extend?

• Extending will NOT increase your likelihood of being audited by the IRS.
• It is better to file an extension than to file a return that is incomplete or that you have not had time to carefully review before signing.

What are the primary benefits of extending my tax return?

• It provides for additional time to file returns without penalty when you are waiting for missing information or tax documents (such as corrected Forms 1099). Just remember that an extension provides additional time to file, but no additional time to pay. Penalties may be assessed if sufficient payment is not remitted with the extension.
• You may qualify for additional retirement planning opportunities or additional time to fund certain types of retirement plans (e.g., SEP IRA).
• It is often less expensive (and easier) to file an extension rather than rushing and possibly needing to amend your return later.

Should I do anything differently if I am filing an extension or “going on extension?”

• No, you still should give your CPA whatever information you have as early as possible or as soon as it becomes available.
• Expect to pay any anticipated taxes owed by the due date.* You still need to submit all available tax information to your CPA promptly so they can determine if you will have a balance due or if you can expect a refund.
• If you are required to make quarterly estimated tax payments, individual first quarter estimated tax payments are due April 15. Your CPA may recommend that you pay the balance due for last year and your first quarter estimated tax payment for this year with your extension.
• If you are anticipating a large refund, your CPA will likely try to get your extended return completed as soon as possible once all tax information is available. Your CPA may also want to discuss tax planning opportunities with you so that, in future years, you don’t give the IRS an interest-free loan.

Have there been any changes to the due dates of returns for this year?

• For tax year 2020, the IRS is postponing the deadline for all individual tax returns.
– Individual returns otherwise due April 15 will not have to be filed until May 17, 2021.
– Certain states have also postponed their filing and/or payment due dates.
• Note that victims of natural disasters may be granted extensions, such as victims of the Texas winter storms have until June 15, 2021 to file various individual and business tax returns and to make payments.

My note: I’d like to add that we take filing extensions for our clients very seriously. We collect as much information as we possibly can about the year’s taxable income and deductions, extrapolate based on information from the prior year, and build a complete tax return — filling in estimates where needed. This way, we get as accurate a picture as we can so as to project how much might be owed to the tax agencies. We do our best, although it’s not perfect, and as a result, much more work is involved in putting together an extension than most folks might think.

More from the IRS on filing extensions here, including a link to file your own for free.


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

How To Cancel Or Reschedule Illinois 2020 Income Tax Return Electronic Payment

As I’m sure you’re aware, the Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) has extended the due date for individual tax filings (but not corporate or estimated taxes) to coincide with the new IRS due date of May 17, 2021.

However, many have already filed their taxes and have scheduled their tax payments to be direct-debited on April 15th. IDOR has released instructions for how to move these payments to the new due date.

From the Illinois Department of Revenue on March 26, 2021:

If you scheduled an electronic payment for 2020 income taxes to be paid on or before April 15, 2021, your payment will not automatically be rescheduled to May 17, 2021. If you do nothing, the payment will be made on the date you chose.

If the payment has not been processed, you may be able to cancel or reschedule it. You must cancel or reschedule the payment before its scheduled date.

Here is information on how to cancel and reschedule your payment:

  • If you scheduled a payment through MyTax Illinois, you can login to your account and cancel any pending payment. If you made your payment through the non-login option, you can use Retrieve Saved or Submitted Request to view and withdraw any pending future payment using the email address and confirmation code associated with your payment. For specific instructions, see Cancel a MyTax Illinois Payment.
  • If you scheduled a payment through a credit card or your bank, you must contact your financial institution to stop the payment. (financial institution stop payment fees may apply.)
  • If you scheduled a payment through a tax professional or using tax preparation software, you may cancel your payment or request the date be changed. You must email us at REV.TaxPay@illinois.gov to make a payment cancellation no later than 11:59 p.m. CT two business days prior to the scheduled payment date and include ALL of the following information:
    1. Your first and last name or your company name if you are a business
    2. Identification number:
      • For individuals, last four of your social security number (SSN) or your Illinois PIN
    3. Mailing address and phone number
    4. Specify if you are requesting to Cancel or Reschedule your payment
    5. Exact dollar amount of your original payment
    6. Date the original payment was scheduled to be paid (Month, Day, and Year)
    7. If rescheduling, you must include the new date to which the payment will be changed.

Note: Checks and money orders are cashed upon receipt. We are unable to stop these transactions, therefore your check or money order will be cashed. You may contact your financial institution for more information regarding your options.


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

What The ARPA, ERC, PPP And Other Laws Mean For Your 2020 Taxes

Recent new legislation from Congress and the White House, as well as guidance from the IRS and DOL, has caused sweeping changes for small business owners and individuals, and we tax preparers are still trying to wrap our heads around it — during what was already the most complex and demanding tax season on record.

Specifically, the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) included a few provisions that are retroactive to 2020 — and the IRS, various state Departments of Revenue, Department of Labor, and tax software programs are trying to figure out how best to implement these changes as efficiently as possible. (For a breakdown of key provisions in the Act, see this excellent summary.)

These changes include:

1) The first $10,200 per person of 2020 unemployment benefits will no longer be taxable at the federal level, though certain states will continue to tax the full amount (Illinois has asked all taxpayers with unemployment income to hold off on filing returns until the Dept of Revenue has addressed the situation). The IRS will be releasing a worksheet that the tax software companies then need to incorporate into the 1040 returns.

2) A 2020 “Repayment Holiday” for the Marketplace Health Insurance Advance Premium Tax Credit was issued, but implementation questions remain; IRS guidance is expected soon.

3) Another economic impact payment (stimulus check) is on its way. You do not need to file your 2020 tax return right now to claim your check, as the law allows for an additional payment in a few months if your 2020 tax return shows you are entitled to more (vs your 2019 tax return). Conversely, if your income went up in 2020 and you are now ineligible for the full benefit, you’ll want to wait to file your 2020 taxes until after your payment arrives, since you won’t have to pay back the overage on your 2021 tax return.

In addition to the above legislative shifts, the IRS recently released guidance concerning the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) that changed our expectation of how it would be handled on business tax returns for cash-basis business tax filers. Previously we had expected that those who received PPP funds in 2020 and can now (as of the Dec 21 Consolidated Appropriations Act) retroactively claim ERC would adjust for the related deductions on their 2021 tax returns. Not so. These adjustments will have to be made on the 2020 tax returns. As a result, we have had to put approximately 75% of our client business returns on extension.

(Technical note: keep in mind if you are doing tax returns for a client that claimed ERC, not only do you have to reduce deductible wages by the amount of the credit, but also recognize this reduction may impact Section 199A eligible wages for purposes of the 20% qualified business income deduction.)

And yet we are still awaiting essential guidance on whether or not the Employee Retention Credit can be taken on wages paid to >50% owners of a company. Interpretations by tax analysts so far are pretty much split evenly between whether the law as [sloppily] written provides reasonable basis in this area.

I’m guessing you see the challenge here: we don’t yet know the rules for claiming the ERC, and yet we have to report related adjustments (as a direct result of the credit calculation) on the 2020 business tax returns. Most of these returns have a flow-through relationship with the business owners’ personal tax returns — so those may have to be placed on extension as well if we do not get guidance soon.

(Related blog post: please call your representatives and ask for all taxes — estimated quarterly as well as corporate — to be extended; not just the Form 1040.)

We are also expecting guidance about how the IRS wants business owners to treat basis reporting for owners where PPP forgiveness causes issues.

Yet another example of a forced need to wait on certain returns: using tax filing software, we can e-file a return today, but set the payment direct-debit date to a future date — not later than the return due-date. This date has not yet been updated in most tax prep systems to go beyond April 15th to the new due date of May 17th.

It’s particularly frustrating for us as small business advocates, because filing a tax return is the only way to get a refund if you’re owed one, and many of our clients may be more in need this year than usual. And yet, for a large number of taxpayers right now, holding off on filing is the recommended approach.

All the while we are trying to help our small business clients respond to 2021 changes, such as important employment law updates; alterations to COBRA and Marketplace subsidies; major modifications to the current round of the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP); new relief programs such as the Shuttered Venue Operators Grant (SVOG) and the Restaurant Revitalization Fund (RRF); the aforementioned ERC/PPP maximization… and so much more.

The provisions noted above — and others — may affect your return. Tax professionals everywhere need some time and space to learn about these changes, analyze their impact, and develop personalized recommendations to maximize your COVID-19 tax benefits. Please be patient with us during this extremely stressful time.


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

PLEASE Ask Congress To Extend Key Tax Filing Dates

As I outlined in a recent post, the IRS extended the individual tax date for filing, but not business and estimated tax dates, which are the ones that small business owners and their tax preparers truly need.

We are asking everyone to please take a moment to contact their Representatives and Senators in Congress to request these types of taxes be included in the recent extension announced by the IRS.

You can share this great article from Money Magazine with them, outlining the issues, or just ask them to google “AICPA tax deadline small business” — there are a ton of great articles that explain why the need for them to act is so great.

From the American Institute of CPAs:

For reference, here’s a copy of my personal message to them — I called and emailed both of my senators as well as my representative.

We in the small business accounting and tax world would immensely appreciate your taking a few moments of your time to help us and our small business clients out — it has been a tax season like no other and we need your assistance to make it to the other side.


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

Tax Day Extended to 5/17… Kinda. Small Businesses Need Your Help!

As I’m sure you’ve heard, it’s official — though it has a lot less meaning and impact than expected. The IRS has moved the individual income tax filing and payment date from the “usual” April 15 to my birthday: May 17, 2021.

But they did not include estimated tax payments or business returns in this extension. Please give me a real birthday present and contact Congress to request this essential small business relief.

IRS Commissioner Rettig neglected to do a few key things that were necessary to assist small business owners and their CPAs:

– Same as last year, the new date was announced after the March 15 deadline for filing S-Corp and Partnership tax returns; due to a long list of new guidance and still-awaited guidance, this forced us to do extra work to put approximately 75% of our clients in this category on extension.
– The extension does not apply to C-Corps and Co-ops, whose returns are still due on the original date of April 15th. This category represents approximately 15% of our struggling small business clients.
– The May 17th extension is only for 2020 tax year filings and, quite problematically, does not apply to first-quarter 2021 estimated taxes due on April 15th, which almost all of our clients are required to pay.

Furthermore, when recently questioned about whether or not there was a way the IRS could help small business owners by coordinating the first-quarter payment with the new deadline, Rettig flatly refused: “no”. Pressed regarding the consequences that not extending this due date would have on small business owners, Rettig said that they had to draw a line somewhere to keep wealthy taxpayers from “gaming the system” (for one month, really?); that small business owners challenged by this could just call the IRS if they have a problem (because that’s been going so well this season?); and tried to point out that the penalties aren’t really that high (so suck it up, and never mind that the state penalties are out of control?).

I cannot begin to express the frustration and disappointment with this decision, and I am not alone.

“The announcement is far too selective in who is receiving relief,” Barry Melancon, AICPA’s president and chief executive, said in a statement. “Failure to include estimated payments nullifies any benefit of a postponement since the tax return work has to be done to calculate estimated payments.”

“While this is welcome news for some taxpayers, there are a number of concerns that this limited extension does not address,” writes Frank Washelesky of ORBA. “The IRS extension does not extend the time for paying first quarter estimated income taxes for the 2021 tax year. It is difficult for taxpayers to determine the amount of the estimated tax required without, at least, a reasonable estimate of their 2020 tax situation. Without an extension of these payments, the filing extension to May 17, 2021 has minimal value for many taxpayers.”

Here’s what the problem is: most small business owners need to pay quarterly estimated taxes to the IRS based on either:
1) 100% of the prior-year’s tax liability; or,
2) 90% of the current-year’s tax liability (which we can’t know yet, so we extrapolate based on the actual profit from the quarter).

Based on a somewhat complex set of rules (which are often different at the state level), small business owners and their tax advisers calculate the actual amount to submit. But they generally need to know both these amounts — which is impossible if their tax return for 2020 hasn’t been filed yet. See why this mismatch in dates is a problem?

And to spice things up even further, not all states are going along with the IRS rules. Taxpayers and their advisers need to check with each agency separately (here’s a good running list at-a-glance). Illinois recently decided to comply with the IRS dates, meaning that the quarterly estimated tax problem exists with our Department of Revenue as well.

“This selective decision by the IRS unfortunately creates more bureaucracy and confusion and is out of sync with real world stresses that taxpayers, tax practitioners and small businesses are dealing with,” said Melancon.

How can you help?

You can call or email your politicians and ask them to include estimated and corporate taxes in the new deadline.

We in the accounting profession would be greatly appreciative if you could contact your Congressional Representatives and Senators and ask them to move ALL tax return and payment due dates, including estimated tax payments and corporate taxes.

I know it’s a pain, but AICPA insists that this type of grassroots work really does have an impact… and if you care about the physical and mental health of your tax preparer, and about the anxiety level and financial well-being of millions of small business owners, you’ll hopefully take a moment to make our request go a bit further.

Thank you!


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.

How To Make IL Dept Of Rev (IDOR) Business Tax And Extension Payments Online

UPDATE 12/31/21: Sigh. The step-by-step instructions I painstakingly wrote out below, with screenshots (for making business replacement income tax estimated and extension payments) are now out-of-date because IDOR revamped their MyTaxIllinois website in September (grrrrr). Please see this blog post instead: How To Make IL Dept Of Rev (IDOR) Business Tax Payments Online: Estimates & Extensions – UPDATED | The Dancing Accountant — the basic concepts are the same, but the layout and workflow is totally different now.


Unlike individual tax payments — extensions, estimated tax, etc. — for business payments you will need to log in to MyTax Illinois, using the same credentials you usually use for paying sales tax or monitoring state payroll taxes.

On the main page, you should see a list of all your accounts with IDOR & IDES, something like this:

Click on the “Business” link. You will see a list of periods.

Click on the period for which you want to make the payment. It is very important to pick the correct period. Keep in mind this is usually the prior year’s ending date, if you’re trying to pay income tax (aka “business replacement tax”) for a return or an extension. You would choose the current year’s ending date if you are trying to make a quarterly estimated tax payment for your business.

Then click “Make a Payment” in the upper-right corner of this portion of the screen, under “I Want To”.

Then click “Bank Account Debit”.

That link will take you to a page where you will select a payment type. It is very important that you select the correct payment type.

They changed the forms a couple of years ago so that there’s no separate extension tax payment form — you just make a payment under the type of income tax form that your business usually files.

For example, a partnership or multi-member LLC would usually select IL-1065 payment — whereas an S-Corp would file an IL-1120-ST. Confirm that you are selecting the correct type that corresponds with your annual business tax return.

It will prompt you to enter your payment information.

And then click Submit. Make sure to save or print the confirmation page that pops up as a pdf — for your files, but also please send it along to your amazing and dedicated tax preparer.

(If you miss that last bit, then please go into your payment history for this account and do a print-screen that includes the status section; it will show the amount, confirmation number, and date/time.)


If this or any other posts on the website were useful to you, and your financial situation permits it, please consider contributing to my tip jar. Ths allows me to continue to provide free accounting resources to small businesses who do not have the funds available to hire a CPA.